A One-of-a-Kind Houseboat on Long Island's Narrow Bay — Yours for $399,000

Two bedrooms, one bathroom, 1,200 square feet, and a spot literally hovering over the water on Narrow Bay in Mastic Beach, New York. This converted houseboat pairs a weathered grey Hamptons-style exterior with mirrored walls, wood-clad ceilings, and a spiral staircase inside — and it comes with property taxes of just $665 a year.

Life, Quite Literally, on the Water

The home sits on a .18-acre lot with a large driveway, storage, a composite bulkhead, and its own dock, with a balcony off the kitchen designed for morning coffee over the bay. Updated electrical, central air, propane heat, and custom windows with electronically controlled shades bring modern comfort to a genuinely unusual setup. Reddit's biggest open question: what winter actually looks like out here, given the fully water-exposed structure.

Worth Knowing Before You Fall in Love

The listing touts an upcoming Brookhaven Town downtown revitalization project and a planned bridge to Smith Point Beach as reasons to buy in now. But local news reporting also shows Brookhaven residents raising real concerns at a recent public hearing about the town potentially acquiring Mastic Beach properties through eminent domain as part of that same redevelopment plan. Nothing about this specific property has been confirmed either way, but it's context worth factoring in before making an offer.

The Internet Has Thoughts

Naturally, this listing caught the attention of Reddit's r/zillowgonewild community. See what people are saying about it here.

A spiral staircase, a private dock, and life right on the bay. View the full listing here.